36 responses |
Saf starts with ... I have been reading about grafting techniques lately and am very interested in trying. Actually my interest in grafting grew from a need - last year I bought a Narrabwen plum without realising that I need a another variety of plum as a cross pollinator. Can someone please suggest a cross pollinator? Few of the sites suggested Mariposa, Satsuma, or Santa Rosa. And also if someone can suggest a place around Sydney Hills district where I can get some cuttings. Happy to pay but certainly I don't want to buy a whole new plant. PS. i am also keen on experimenting with grafting a lime onto my establish lemon tree. | About the Author Saf Baulkham Hills 23rd July 2012 1:45pm #UserID: 6317 Posts: 6 View All Saf's Edible Fruit Trees |
||||||
About the Author Itdepends 23rd July 2012 8:20pm #UserID: 7076 Posts: 4 View All Itdepends's Edible Fruit Trees |
|||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
About the Author peter 1000 adelaide 23rd July 2012 9:07pm #UserID: 6592 Posts: 102 View All peter 1000's Edible Fruit Trees |
|||||||
Reply |
| Remember to
LIKE this Answer(0)
LIKE this Question (0)
Original Post was last edited: 23rd July 2012 9:35pm | |||||||
Saf says... Hi Peter 1000, Thanks for the offer - very kind of you. Yes I would love some scion wood. Since you are in Adelaide (and I am in Sydney) not sure if sending via mail would be alright. I am happy to pay (or at least for the postage). Please email me your address and I can send through a prepaid postage satchel and my address. My email is "2145(at)exemail(dot)com(dot)au". | About the Author Saf Baulkham Hills 31st July 2012 10:54am #UserID: 6317 Posts: 6 View All Saf's Edible Fruit Trees |
||||||
About the Author peter 1000 adelaide 31st July 2012 2:29pm #UserID: 6592 Posts: 102 View All peter 1000's Edible Fruit Trees |
|||||||
About the Author Boris Spasky 31st July 2012 11:00pm #UserID: 7085 Posts: 184 View All Boris Spasky's Edible Fruit Trees |
|||||||
CH says... I am looking at buying a dwarf Mariposa plum and would like to attempt to graft or bud a cutting of dwarf Satsuma onto the same rootstock to enable it to cross pollinate. Does anyone have any advice on doing this, is it a good idea? If so what is the best method to use to attach the Satsuma onto the Mariposa rootstock but on the opposite side to the Mariposa branch? If I attempt this will it damage the Mariposa? Also, what is the best time of year to do it? Thanks. C | About the Author CH Melbourne 3rd July 2014 8:19pm #UserID: 22767 Posts: 25 View All CH's Edible Fruit Trees |
||||||
Markmelb says... The rootstock causes the dwarfing - attach any of those scions to a low branch - I have a plumcot with 7 different - just use a whip and tongue graft on a lowish branch - find a tree first that suits this to make it easy - maybe go to a grafting day and practice on some prunings till your happy with join - good luck :) | About the Author Markmelb , 3rd July 2014 9:28pm #UserID: 7785 Posts: 1192 View All Markmelb's Edible Fruit Trees |
||||||
About the Author BenW Kinglake West,3757,VIC 3rd July 2014 10:15pm #UserID: 5390 Posts: 144 View All BenW's Edible Fruit Trees |
|||||||
CH says... Thanks for the advice guys. I am not sure if the whip and tongue graft is the best method as I was wanting to graft it onto the rootstock in a different place so that I can distinguish between the different varieties. Is there another way to do this - is it a good idea? Also when is the best time of the year to do it, is it something I need to start in the next few weeks or is it best to wait until Spring or Summer? | About the Author CH Melbourne 7th July 2014 5:50pm #UserID: 22767 Posts: 25 View All CH's Edible Fruit Trees |
||||||
Reply |
| Remember to
LIKE this Answer(0)
LIKE this Question (0)
Original Post was last edited: 7th July 2014 5:50pm | |||||||
About the Author Jason Portland 8th July 2014 2:46am #UserID: 637 Posts: 1217 View All Jason's Edible Fruit Trees |
|||||||
Reply |
| Remember to
LIKE this Answer(0)
LIKE this Question (0)
Original Post was last edited: 8th July 2014 2:46am | |||||||
BenW says... CH, do you have you rootstock / Mariposa already? If not, choose one with 3 or 4 well spaced branches. Make sure it has good crotch angles and that the branches originate for the trunk a little ways apart (definitely not in a Y shape). This will give you a strong framework and reduce the risk of broken branches and disease in the long run. This will be easy to grow in an open vase and you can replace one or two of the branches with other varieties, by cutting the branches quite short and grafting on. Cutting them short will make your tree easy to manage as you will know which variety is where, without new shoots mucking things up. Whip and tongue is perfect. If it is a maiden tree (single stem) I would cut it back a bit (to where it is at least pencil thickness) and graft on top. New branches will grow from beneath your graft and will be the trees original variety, while those from your graft will be the new variety. One think I would definitely not do is side wedge graft. I've seen this done to add multiple varieties to a rootstock in 1 year, however the arising branches will never be strong and will almost certainly break in a few years. This technique is meant for a single graft, and once that graft has taken you would cut everything above it off. If you're not sure, I recommend you attend either the Heritage fruits society grafting day at Pettys Orchard in Templestowe or the Werribbee park heritage orchard grafting day. Both are coming up in the next month or so. I'll be at the Petty's orchard one, as I have helped with the grafting there the past couple of years. They won't have dwarf rootstock, as they are new and hard to get,get some tips (a photo of your tree will help, if you don't want to bring it along) and a wide variety of scion - 100+ varieties if you are lucky, but definitely more than you'll find elsewhere. | About the Author BenW Kinglake West,3757,VIC 8th July 2014 7:48pm #UserID: 5390 Posts: 144 View All BenW's Edible Fruit Trees |
||||||
Reply |
| Remember to
LIKE this Answer(0)
LIKE this Question (0)
Original Post was last edited: 8th July 2014 7:48pm | |||||||
About the Author srt giraween 9th July 2014 1:39pm #UserID: 10109 Posts: 83 View All srt's Edible Fruit Trees |
|||||||
CH says... Thanks Jason and BenW. BenW thanks for taking the time to give such a detailed response- no, I haven’t bought the Mariposa yet as I have only found Satsuma and Santa Rose dwarf varieties on sale but there is a nursery I am going to visit where I purchased my other dwarf varieties (peach, nectarine and apricot) from last year I am quite hopeful will have it. I will try and make sure that if I am able to find one it matches the description you have provided as best I can. So you believe that trying to graft the Satsuma to the Mariposa’s rootstock is a bad idea because it won't take and will break? Petty’s Orchard is apparently less than 10 minutes away from where I live so I will definitely try and make it down there on the 4th for the Grafting Day - thanks so much for letting me know about it! I’ve never tried grafting but am quite eager to learn. I tried looking at their website but it didn’t show costs for it all, do you know what they are? They also didn’t say if they have dwarf rootstock varieties, but am I right that grafting normal varieties onto dwarf rootstock means that they will grow to dwarf size due to the rootstock? | About the Author CH Melbourne 9th July 2014 3:45pm #UserID: 22767 Posts: 25 View All CH's Edible Fruit Trees |
||||||
BenW says... Hi CH The problem isn't with the combination you want - plums are pretty forgiving. You shouldn't graft a European plum onto a Japanese, but you can go the other way. That's about it. (the ones you mention are all Japanese). The problem I was talking about relates to side wedge grafting, which is a method sometimes used to add a number of varieties in one go. I pulled an image from the web. See how upright the graft is, and how close to the main stem? That join will never heal strongly and will probably break when it gets heavy with fruit. It would be OK if you cut off the main stem once the graft took, but that defeats the purpose :) The best thing to do is find a tree with branches in the right spots for an open vase: 3-5 branches spaced around the tree, vertically separated on the trunk, with good angles from the trunk. Google open vase to get some images. Even if your tree isn't perfect, new branches you can use will probably grow and you can graft onto them next year. Petty's probably won't have dwarf rootstock for plums. These are a very new release, not widely available, except for those Plantnet tagged dwarf stone fruit trees that have appeared the last couple of years, so if you really want a dwarf, you will need to buy one of those. I'm pretty sure I saw some in Bunnings the other day. I keep my full size plums to 2 ish meters tall with summer pruning, and they will be hardier than dwarfs. You need to commit to diligent pruning though. I'm not sure what the current prices at Petty's are. Scion is usually 2 or 3 dollars a piece, and a couple more if you want someone to do the graft for you. Rootstock maybe $10, but these would be much better suited for a single graft. I help out there from time to time but I try to avoid having much to do with the administrative side of things, so if you want to know for sure, email them :)
| About the Author BenW Kinglake West,3757,VIC 10th July 2014 12:36am #UserID: 5390 Posts: 144 View All BenW's Edible Fruit Trees |
||||||
CH says... Thanks for the clarification Ben, by the sounds of it sacrificing 1 branch on the plum for a whip and tongue graft is the way to go, especially if it is the best way to ensure I get any plums at all! The Plantnet varieties are the ones I have seen and am going to get – they are the only dwarf plums I have seen anywhere (and the 2 varieties I mentioned seeing above were at Bunnings also). On the ones I have seen the crotch angle seemed to be about 45 degrees with the branches growing mostly straight upwards, does this sounds okay? Most of them seem to have about 4 main branches growing up quite high and quite close together. I’ll contact Petty’s to find out the details :) | About the Author CH Melbourne 10th July 2014 3:05pm #UserID: 22767 Posts: 25 View All CH's Edible Fruit Trees |
||||||
BenW says... No worries CH, glad it made sense :) 45-60 degrees is about right for your scaffold branches. You can tie branches down(or up) to a good angle while they are young. If you can easily bend the branch to the right angle, it's fine. If it looks or feels like it is putting stress where it joins the trunk when you do it, don't count that as a scaffold branch as you really should cut it off. I have reused a picture of a peach I posted a week or so ago. It's a bit hard to see, but the angles at the trunk are good and they are nicely spaced branches. The branches are a bit upright, but can easily be tied down to good angles. Just choose the best tree you can find. Most problems can be fixed if you do it while the tree is young. To be honest, you could choose the worst tree there, bung it in the ground and never prune or care for it and it would probably still fruit just fine. By taking care at this stage though, your tree will be easier to manage, with less chance of disease, split branches, ect.
| About the Author BenW Kinglake West,3757,VIC 11th July 2014 1:11pm #UserID: 5390 Posts: 144 View All BenW's Edible Fruit Trees |
||||||
Reply |
| Remember to
LIKE this Answer(0)
LIKE this Question (0)
Original Post was last edited: 11th July 2014 1:10pm | |||||||
CH says... Thanks again Ben. They all looked the same so I doubted that there would be a problem with all of them. If I may bother you with a couple more questions, I am looking at buying the plum over the next few days but it will be bare-rooted so will need potting. How long will it need before I can attempt to graft a Satsuma cutting onto it? If I attempt it in a month (say at the grafting day) will it take or because the tree is still establishing itself will it struggle? If I am also able to get a cutting of the Satsuma in the next few days how long will it survive by itself before it needs to be grafted on or dies? | About the Author CH Melbourne 11th July 2014 5:36pm #UserID: 22767 Posts: 25 View All CH's Edible Fruit Trees |
||||||
BenW says... Hey CH I've always be told to graft plums a little later, in August (for Victoria)when the sap is starting to run. It would probably be fine now as well. It is actually OK if the rootstock isn't 100% dormant, so long as the scion (your cutting)is. If you need to store scion, put it in an airtight ziplock bag in the fridge with a little damp sphagnum or wrapped in damp newspaper - just damp, not sopping. It will keep that way for months. Personally, I would plant my tree now - the less time it is barerooted the better. If you aren't 100% confident on the grafting part, store your scion for now and there will be demos at the grafting day which might help. Grafting satsuma on now and then adding another variety after the grafting day would also work just fine I would think. My suggestion - read about the techniques, preferably watch a video or 2 on youtube, then practice grafting bits of prunings together until you get nice joins. I do this every year before I try any real grafts :) | About the Author BenW Kinglake West,3757,VIC 11th July 2014 10:58pm #UserID: 5390 Posts: 144 View All BenW's Edible Fruit Trees |
||||||
About the Author For eddy Manly 12th July 2014 1:20pm #UserID: 10099 Posts: 14 View All For eddy's Edible Fruit Trees |
|||||||
About the Author BenW Kinglake West,3757,VIC 12th July 2014 5:26pm #UserID: 5390 Posts: 144 View All BenW's Edible Fruit Trees |
|||||||
About the Author CH Melbourne 13th July 2014 9:42pm #UserID: 22767 Posts: 25 View All CH's Edible Fruit Trees |
|||||||
About the Author Markmelb , 13th July 2014 10:47pm #UserID: 7785 Posts: 1192 View All Markmelb's Edible Fruit Trees |
|||||||
BenW says... Where did you get your CotNCandy Mark? I have looked for some of the Flemings interspecifics but so far only found a Pluot and Plumcot. They are rubbish from the shops but what stonefruit isn't? Worth a try in my book. I wouldn't mind trying some of the others, where the bulk of the genetics is from apricots or peaches. | About the Author BenW Kinglake West,3757,VIC 15th July 2014 3:48pm #UserID: 5390 Posts: 144 View All BenW's Edible Fruit Trees |
||||||
CH says... BenW, is the grafting day on tomorrow? I have tried accessing Petty's website to check the day but the website is currently down. Will the rain cause the day to be called off? I was thinking about bringing my Mariposa and scions with me so someone can help me with the graft but now that it is potted I don't think it will fit in my car! | About the Author CH Melbourne 2nd August 2014 12:21pm #UserID: 22767 Posts: 25 View All CH's Edible Fruit Trees |
||||||
BenW says... Should be on CH. It's winter. In Melbourne. Rain isn't exactly unheard of ;)If not many people turn up, they might finish up early though. Attached is a flyer I had emailed to me: http://www.heritagefruitssociety.org.au/Resources/Pictures/HFS%20Grafting%20Days%20poster%202014.jpg You will definitely be able to get a demo I would say. I don't think I'm on grafting duty this year but I'll probably still be around pruning or cutting scion or something. You said earlier you are only a few minutes away? If you aren't confident after tomorrow, I could drop by after the next Petty's work day in two weeks. I really do encourage you to have a go yourself though. Even a noob should get 80% success with plums (95% with apples or pears):D If it fails it doesn't matter really - You will get another chance next year anyway. | About the Author BenW Kinglake West,3757,VIC 2nd August 2014 1:52pm #UserID: 5390 Posts: 144 View All BenW's Edible Fruit Trees |
||||||
About the Author CH Melbourne 2nd August 2014 7:34pm #UserID: 22767 Posts: 25 View All CH's Edible Fruit Trees |
|||||||
CH says... Thanks again for all your help yesterday Ben, it was great to put a face to the name. I practised the grafting on the branches you gave me but am having trouble getting a clean straight cut the first time - I believe it may be due to not having a proper grafting knife. I went to Bunnings to get one but they didn't have any - is there a place you know of that sell them or are they an online job? Also can you remember what the name of the blood plum cutting the flannel shirt guy recommended was? Was it Brown's blood? | About the Author CH Melbourne 4th August 2014 2:34pm #UserID: 22767 Posts: 25 View All CH's Edible Fruit Trees |
||||||
BenW says... Hi Chris Just glad to see someone younger than me interested in fruit trees :D If you are having trouble getting a nice cut, that seems likely. Either that, or your angle is a bit off (if you make the cut more than say 2cm, you get a wavy cut), or you are putting the tongue cut in the wrong position perhaps? I got one at the Seymour field days about 5 years ago, and another at a budding day, I don't actually know where to buy one off the shelf. Online might be the way to go. These look Ok to me http://www.forestrytools.com.au/index.php?id=405 http://www.forestrytools.com.au/index.php?id=404 Good luck :) And yes, it was browns blood. Got a piece of that one myself... | About the Author BenW Kinglake West,3757,VIC 4th August 2014 10:54pm #UserID: 5390 Posts: 144 View All BenW's Edible Fruit Trees |
||||||
Markmelb says... Hi CH - I got my 405 from BAAG - Ive reshaped it into a true triangle and polished it and shaves hair now -- see link https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jav_AQjgQrQ | About the Author Markmelb , 5th August 2014 8:15am #UserID: 7785 Posts: 1192 View All Markmelb's Edible Fruit Trees |
||||||
CH says... Cheers Ben, I will keep practising because it might have been because the angle was off, it definitely had that wavy look to it. I’ll try and keep it to about 2cm. I was trying to look up Brown’s blood but couldn’t find anything on it, thought I must have had it wrong. Let me know how it goes because I might try that one next year! Mark thanks for the advice, I have contacted BAAG about whether they have them in stock and will probably pop down there on the weekend to get one. I’m not sure what you mean about the reshaping it to a ‘true triangle’ comment though? | About the Author CH Melbourne 7th August 2014 3:53pm #UserID: 22767 Posts: 25 View All CH's Edible Fruit Trees |
||||||
Reply |
| Remember to
LIKE this Answer(1)
LIKE this Question (0)
People who Like this Answer: For eddy | |||||||
BenW says... They come 'blunt' Chris - I had forgotten the one I had with me was new :) You will do better if you sharpen it before use, like Mark has. If you are really serious, you use a leather strap and sharpen it like a cutthroat razor at regular intervals as you work. So long as you keep it reasonably sharp, you'll be right :) | About the Author BenW Kinglake West,3757,VIC 7th August 2014 4:34pm #UserID: 5390 Posts: 144 View All BenW's Edible Fruit Trees |
||||||
Markmelb says... CH - the Video link above explains the triangle blade shape - flat on bottom and blade goes from thick at rear to nothing at edge so no 45deg edge or whatever like a knife - i think i used 400 wet and dry wet and down to 100 then polished with leather as he explains and then fibreglass polish compound and the leather strap I made - totally different technique to a knife :) | About the Author Markmelb , 7th August 2014 9:20pm #UserID: 7785 Posts: 1192 View All Markmelb's Edible Fruit Trees |
||||||
About the Author For eddy Manly 9th August 2014 12:43am #UserID: 10099 Posts: 14 View All For eddy's Edible Fruit Trees |
|||||||
CH says... Thanks heaps guys for helping out, I can't believe how willing you all are to share your knowledge like this - it's awesome and very much appreciated. Mark I hadn't had the chance to check out the video properly but now I understand what you are talking about - thanks for the explanation. I've decided to just give it a go and hope for the best, if it doesn't work I'll try again next year. Fingers crossed! | About the Author CH Melbourne 9th August 2014 10:39am #UserID: 22767 Posts: 25 View All CH's Edible Fruit Trees |
||||||
About the Author Markmelb , 6th January 2015 10:11pm #UserID: 7785 Posts: 1192 View All Markmelb's Edible Fruit Trees |
|||||||
BlackThumbed says... Hi everyone! So, at the moment I have a semi-dormant peachcot tree that i'd love to graft some blood plums onto. Firstly, would this combination even work? I know that most stone fruits can be inter-grafted, but i've never really heard of this combination before (peachcot or nectarine base, plum top) Also, I have one of those 'grafting tools' (image attached) that i've used to try and graft in the past. Could I still use it for this? Finally, would anyone be generous enough to provide some scionwood of the Santa Rosa, Mariposa, Satsuma or Cot-n-candy cultivar? I would offer some of my peach, nectarine or peachcot scionwood but unfortunately the weather in Melbourne has been unusually warm and all my trees have already flowered and leafed out! Thank you all so much and if you have any more grafting tips please enlighten me haha. BlackThumbed | About the Author BlackThumbed Malvern east 13th August 2018 1:25pm #UserID: 16240 Posts: 38 View All BlackThumbed's Edible Fruit Trees |
||||||